Last time we checked under our sofa cushions we found some random LEGOs, a plastic dinosaur, and a few kernels of very old popcorn. Not long ago, a Canadian woman fared quite a bit better when she discovered a rare Rolex Daytona Paul Newman in her $25 thrift store sofa. After she unsuccessfully tried to find the owner (more than we would do), she took the timepiece to watch dealer Paul Altieri who assessed it at a cool quarter mil and subsequently paid her for it. Though it’s not valued at the $15.5 million Newman’s own Daytona commanded at auction back in 2017, it easily eclipses the value of all of our furniture and the contents within.
More Watches
Black Book: 14 Products Our Editors Loved in May 2026
The products our editors have been obsessed with in May 2026.
A Curated List of Memorial Day Sales
The internet is on sale. Here’s where to start.
Watch of the Month: Bulova CURV 10th Anniversary Edition
Featuring the world’s first curved chronograph movement (accurate to seconds/year), it still feels like the future a decade later.